Young Teens Who Accept Other Bodies but Not Their Own

Ein dicker chinesischer Schulberater in senfgelbem Hemd steht lachend an einem Fenster im Flur einer Mittelschule und spricht mit einer Lehrerin. KI-generiertes Motiv, keine realen Personen. / A fat Chinese school counselor in a mustard shirt stands laughing by a window in a junior high school corridor, talking with a teacher. AI-generated image, no real people.

A survey of 1,248 Chinese junior high school students found three body image profiles. Most students liked their bodies. The second-largest group, almost one in four, appreciated other people’s bodies but not their own. This article reports how the study was built, what its tables contain and what it cannot say. It reports the paper’s content. It does not recommend, evaluate or describe any diet, eating pattern or weight goal.

The paper is “Body image and maladaptive eating behaviors in Chinese early adolescents: a latent profile analysis” by Chungan Zhang, Yichu Han, Shuhua Cheng and Yuqian Qi. It appeared in Frontiers in Psychology, volume 17, article 1879943 (doi 10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1879943), open access under CC BY 4.0, published online on 2 October 2026. Fatosphere read the full text and Tables 1 to 5. The reference list and the figure were not checked.

What the study is

A cross-sectional questionnaire study, analysed with latent profile analysis (LPA). LPA sorts people into groups with similar score patterns. Here the patterns are made of four body image scores: three kinds of positive body image and one measure of body dissatisfaction. The authors then asked who ends up in which group and how the groups differ on three eating scales.

Positive body image was measured with a Chinese version of the Positive Body Image among Adolescents Scale. It has three parts: appreciating one’s own body, appreciating other people’s bodies, and coping with negative comments about one’s appearance. The authors cut the original 15 items to 10. They dropped the media-resilience items because students found them hard to understand, and three more items after a factor analysis. Body dissatisfaction came from the general appearance subscale of a Chinese negative physical self scale.

Who was in it

1,350 students from three junior high schools in Heilongjiang Province were invited by cluster sampling. They filled in paper questionnaires in class. After removing incomplete and invalid answers, 1,248 remained (92.44 percent). Average age 13.42, range 12 to 15. 629 boys and 619 girls. 490 in Grade 7, 470 in Grade 8, 288 in Grade 9. An ethics committee at Harbin Normal University approved the study and waived written consent.

The paper says BMI was calculated and converted into age- and sex-adjusted z-scores using Chinese national reference values. It does not report an average BMI, a range, or how many students had a high weight. Table 1 has no BMI row. Nobody reading the paper can tell how many fat children are in the sample.

The three profiles

The authors tested models with one to five profiles. The three-profile model won on their combined criteria. Entropy, a measure of how cleanly people sort into groups, is 0.86, above the 0.80 the authors call acceptable.

ProfileStudentsShareSelf-appreciationOther-appreciationBody dissatisfaction
Positive body image83166.59 %6.496.881.72
Other-appreciation dominant29823.88 %4.856.503.11
Moderate body image1199.54 %3.973.993.31
Bar chart / Balkendiagramm
Graphic: Fatosphere Editorial

Appreciation scores run from 1 to 7, body dissatisfaction from 1 to 5. The second group scores almost as high as the first on appreciating others (6.50 against 6.88) but about 1.6 points lower on appreciating itself than the first group. The authors read this as a contradictory state: accepting diverse bodies in others and struggling to extend that to oneself.

Who ends up in the second group

The authors predicted group membership from gender, BMI and family socioeconomic status, with the positive group as reference (Table 4).

Girls had 96 percent higher odds than boys of being in the other-appreciation group (OR 1.96, 95 percent CI 1.36 to 2.82). Per unit of BMI, the odds were 32 percent higher (OR 1.32, CI 1.16 to 1.51). Socioeconomic status did not predict membership (OR 0.95, CI 0.80 to 1.13). Neither gender nor BMI separated the moderate group from the positive group.

The authors offer an explanation for the BMI result: children with a higher BMI, facing weight-related social pressure, may take on a broad idea of beauty as a way to accept themselves, yet fail to apply it to their own body. Our reading: this is an interpretation, not a result. The study measured neither weight stigma nor the reasons for the broad idea of beauty, and it tested no such route.

The eating scales

Three subscales of the Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire were used, each scored 1 to 5. The paper defines restrained eating as the tendency to diet to lower or keep a body weight, emotional eating as eating in response to feelings, and external eating as eating in response to food cues.

ProfileRestrainedEmotionalExternal
Positive body image2.331.922.92
Other-appreciation dominant2.721.942.92
Moderate body image2.762.212.94

Restrained eating was higher in both other groups than in the positive group (both p < 0.001). Emotional eating was higher in the moderate group than in the other two (p < 0.05). External eating did not differ.

Where the numbers need care

Cross-sectional means no direction. Everything was measured at one time. The paper says causal conclusions are not possible. The wording “associated with” is the right one.

The differences are small in size. The restrained-eating gap between the positive group and the others is about 0.4 points on a 5-point scale. Emotional eating differs by 0.3 points between the smallest group and the rest. The paper gives no effect sizes for these comparisons. Our reading: statistically significant here does not mean large.

The profile count rests on a threshold. The four-profile model had a group of 3.21 percent, which the authors dropped because it fell under their 5 percent rule. By our arithmetic that is about 40 students. The paper does not describe that group. The authors note that a “strong negative, weak positive” profile, common in other studies, is absent here, and say the most extreme form may appear later in development. That is a guess, not a finding.

Two of the four scales are adapted. The body image scale was shortened and translated, and one dimension was removed. The authors report good fit and a correlation of 0.69 with another body appreciation scale. Group shares may differ with the full instrument.

One unit of BMI is unclear. The methods describe BMI z-scores. The results text speaks of a one-unit increase in BMI. The paper does not say which is meant.

Eating scores are self-reports. They describe what students say about themselves on questionnaires. They are not a diagnosis, and the paper does not link them to any health outcome.

What the study cannot show

Anything about fat children as a group. Without a reported weight distribution, the BMI result cannot be placed. We do not know whether it comes from a few high values or a broad shift.

Why the groups differ. The explanations on objectification and coping are theory. They were not tested.

Anything beyond three schools in one province. The authors name this as a limit.

Whether any programme works. The authors suggest school-based prevention and support for the other-appreciation group. No programme was tested here. We report the suggestion and take no position on it.

The frame and the interests

The paper treats eating scores as risk markers and body image as something to protect. Its conclusion calls for targeted prevention. Fatosphere reports this frame as the authors’ own. The funding statement says no financial support was received. The conflict-of-interest statement declares no commercial or financial relationships. The authors state that generative AI was not used to create the manuscript. Data are available from the authors on request.

How it connects to our other work

For another cross-sectional comparison with weight status, see Body Unease Tracks Weight Status More Than Age. For the same method in a different sample, see Weight Stigma and Compulsive Exercise: Few Fat Students in the Sample. For background, see our guide on fat body and mental health.

Source: Zhang C, Han Y, Cheng S, Qi Y. “Body image and maladaptive eating behaviors in Chinese early adolescents: a latent profile analysis.” Front Psychol 2026;17:1879943, doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1879943, PMC13672202. Title, authors, journal, volume, article number, date and license read from the Europe PMC full-text record and checked against Crossref. Full text read on 27 October 2026.